Question: What Is ‘Starvation’?

April 14, 2012 10 Comments
By

If you answered ‘This’, congrats!


If, on the other hand, you read this headline in the ‘Evening Standard’, you could be forgiven for wondering if it was still the 1st April:


Because it now seems that the new definition of ‘starvation’ is this:

At least, according to Camila Batmanghelidjh, founder and chief executive (and inveterate self-publicist) of charity Kids Company:

“The number of children coming to us with hunger problems has increased five-fold in a decade and the number of children self-referring on a daily basis has doubled in the last year.

“We are struggling to cope with the scale of this silent epidemic of hunger. More than 60 per cent of the 2,000 children we help every week tell us there is no food at home and 85 per cent rely on us for their main meal of the day.”

Hmmm, let’s hear some case stories, shall we?

On a visit to their Kenbury Street site in Camberwell, the Standard saw 250 children hunker down to a lunch of barbecued chicken, hot-dogs, salad and coleslaw.

Among them was 10-year-old Alex who said: “I come here every day after school for my main meal. I come because I like the food, and because I used to go hungry at home. I’d get really, really hungry. I’d tell my mum, Why can’t I have a hot supper like the other children?’ Often I had to make a sandwich for dinner or eat biscuits.”

A sandwich for dinner’s not ideal. But it’s not ‘starvation’. And more to the point, it’s not conclusive proof that Alex’s mum can’t afford to feed her child, either. Maybe she has other priorities?

Kids Company key worker Lee Anderson, 41, said that the conditions they found some children living in was “frankly inhumane”. “I work with a 10-year-old called Chris and his two older brothers, both of whom have lost their four adult front teeth due to extreme malnourishment. They live with their mother since their alcoholic father was jailed for domestic violence. I will never forget when we visited their house because it took four of us nine hours to clean up just the kitchen. We found dog faeces in the cupboards.”

Eh..?

Now, unless they had a really, really bad computer mix-up at the on-line grocery order that day, in order to have dog faeces in a cupboard, wouldn’t you also have to have a dog?
How could you afford to feed it (given that, if faeces were produced, you have to have fed it!) and not your kids?
And is ‘starvation’ the reason for keeping the sort of house where you have to wipe your feet after you leave?

Oh, and little Chris wasn’t starving at all.

The only food Chris ever ate was McDonald’s and fizzy drinks. Over the months, we have changed his eating habits and we’ve started to see a change in his behaviour.”

Well, that’s nice to know, and I’m sure you believe you’re doing good, but perhaps, the next time you look at your income tax bill, you might just start to wonder why so much of your money goes in tax to support a welfare state that can swoop on innocent parents while apparently not caring too much about living conditions that would make a pig gag…

Ms Batmanghelidjh called on the mayoral candidates to try to imagine life from the point of view of a desolate child. “The poorest children in London don’t have a voice. I’d like to see Boris and Ken urgently address this issue in their election manifestos. We have a collective responsibility to make sure every child in London always has enough to eat. This is a basic human need and a basic human right. And it is something we can solve as a society, if we want to.”

I’m afraid I disagree – the feeding of children is their parent’s responsibility, not mine. My responsibility is limited to paying tax to fund the welfare state.

If that’s not working as it should, don’t come to me for extra money to plug the gap. You won’t get it. I’m hardening my heart.

Tags: , , , ,

10 Responses to Question: What Is ‘Starvation’?

  1. David A. Evans
    April 14, 2012 at 9:56 am

    Ms Batmanghelidjh.

    Roughly translated, Ms. BatshitCrazy

    DaveE.

  2. ivan
    April 14, 2012 at 10:32 am

    What is she complaining about? Kids Company is a fake charity which all taxpayers pay for but get little or nothing in return.

    I very much doubt there are any children in England that are starving – they may think they are but in reality they are mostly over fed and going without once in a while would do them good.

    • Mudplugger
      April 14, 2012 at 4:02 pm

      No taxpayers’ money should ever go to ‘charities’ like this. We fund the Welfare State for genuine need – if it’s not doing the business, then we should make it.
      If anyone wishes to give their own money to bat-shit crazy women like this one, so be it, it’s a free country, just don’t give her any of my money.

      • April 15, 2012 at 5:55 am

        Spot on! I want to decide for myself, not have government pick ‘deserving causes’ for me.

  3. Tattyfalarr
    April 14, 2012 at 11:43 am

    I come because I like the food, and because I used to go hungry at home

    Serve food they don’t like and we’ll see who’s starving, shall we. :|

    • April 15, 2012 at 5:55 am

      :)

  4. stab11
    April 14, 2012 at 2:08 pm

    An interesting thing about Ms Batmanghelidjh is the almost religious following she inspires. If there is any criticism of her online then her followers have a strange habit of appearing and becoming quite abusive of anyone who dares not to believe. The funny thing is when they are challenged to say what exactly their great one does they vanish as quickly as they came.

  5. john in cheshire
    April 14, 2012 at 4:25 pm

    Ms Batmanghelidjh – yet another immigrant wanting something for nothing. Perhaps her efforts would be put to better purpose if she returned to Iran.

  6. April 15, 2012 at 11:44 am

    In UK terms, I’m in a dire situation, yet last evening, I had soup, chilli main dish, with accompaniments, a nice wine and apple crumble for afters, with a cafe latte. Plus I blogged.

    • April 15, 2012 at 2:16 pm

      :) Exactly!

United Kingdom Time

Subscribe

Email us at contact orphans of liberty [all one word] at gmail dot com

Authors

For more about these renegades, click on the name to go to a short profile:

AK Haart
Churchmouse
James Higham
JuliaM
The Quiet Man

Orphans logo


Feel free to take this for your sidebar.